Feminist Frequency @femfreq
The Avengers' Black Widow is not subverting any sexist
stereotypes, she's clearly just
the tired old femme fatale
trope.
12:55 PM 9 May 12
Mophead F@mopheadfI'm not accustomed to the Femme Fatale having a lead combat role or besting her partner in CQC (close quarters combat).
12:57 PM 9 May 12
Anthony Oliveira@oliveiranthBlack Widow doesn't subvert sexist stereotypes; she uses them as an extremely effective weapon. That is remarkable if not PC. (cc @Femfreq)
12:58 PM 9 May 12
Feminist Frequency @femfreq
.@oliveiranth Black Widow uses faked emotions and pseudo vulnerability to manipulate men into giving her information, it's not remarkable.
1:00 PM 9 May 12
Anthony Oliveira@oliveiranth@femfreq Except that when she does it, the audience cheers. She is a standard femme fatale, w the notable difference of being the hero.
1:02 PM 9 May 12
Feminist Frequency @femfreq
@oliveiranth The audience also cheered when Thresh based [sic] in Clove's head and killed her during the Hunger Games...
1:03 PM 9 May 12
Anthony Oliveira@oliveiranth@femfreq well, bc the audience in that case was horrible. My point is that the mechanics of the story do not punish her for her "womanly" wiles that when she does it, the audience cheers.
1:04 PM 9 May 12
Mophead F@mopheadf@femfreq @oliveiranth Sad to see feminists devaluing women's labour, skills and contributions, even in fiction.
1:04 PM 9 May 12
Anthony Oliveira@oliveiranth@mopheadf @femfreq yes precisely; prescribing how women shld/shld not use their bodies makes them no better than the ideology we claim to oppose.
1:06 PM 9 May 12
Feminist Frequency @femfreq
@oliveiranth No, she's not punished, and that's good, but she's still a stereotypical sexist trope, regardless of whether she's "likeable"
1:06 PM 9 May 12
Feminist Frequency @femfreq
@mopheadf @oliveiranth It's possible to like Black Widow or even The Avengers movie & acknowledge she's fulfilling a sexist trope.
1:07 PM 9 May 12
Anthony Oliveira@oliveiranth @femfreq Yes, she is - and acknowledged as one. She is explicitly a "Black Widow." But that's low-hanging fruit.
1:08 PM 9 May 12
Anthony Oliveira@oliveiranth@femfreq @mopheadf Ah, well, that's different. But you called her "a tired old" sexist trope. She isn't that; she is a fascinating revision.
1:09 PM 9 May 12
Anthony Oliveira@oliveiranth@femfreq @mopheadf She says "love is a game for children." I suspect she would say the same about political correctness.
1:11 PM 9 May 12
Feminist Frequency @femfreq
@oliveiranth "Politically Correct" is a term by the right to silence conversations about oppression and privilege.
1:14 PM 9 May 12
Anthony Oliveira@oliveiranth@femfreq @mopheadf My point is merely that BW values efficacy over ideology, and the story rewards, not punishes that ethos.
1:19 PM 9 May 12
Mophead F@mopheadf@oliveiranth @femfreq I would also say that Black Widow displays a lot of consciousness, using sexist stereotypes to her advantage.
1:25 PM 9 May 12
Feminist Frequency @femfreq
@mopheadf I don't think it's valuable or honorable for females to use "sexist stereotypes to her advantage". It's still sexist.
1:37 PM 9 May 12
Mophead F@mopheadf.@femfreq She understands that she lives in a sexist society and uses the villians' assumptions about women against them.
1:39 PM 9 May 12
Sandra @rhiannon1307
@femfreq So you're basically denying her the right to use a certain talent and ability? Hm. Somehow can't see how that makes you a feminist.
1:40 PM 9 May 12
Feminist Frequency @femfreq
@mopheadf That doesn't mean she isn't still doing SEXISM...or rather, isn't still written as actively participating in sexism.
1:40 PM 9 May 12
Mophead F@mopheadf.@femfreq Are you saying that her way of using subterfuge to gain intel is a sexist act?
1:42 PM 9 May 12
Feminist Frequency @femfreq
@rhiannon1307 Your questioning my feminist cred because I think that using fake emotions to manipulate men is a sexist narrative trope?!
1:42 PM 9 May 12
Sandra @rhiannon1307
@femfreq Yes I am. Becasue you're implying one form of feminity is superior to the other. And, furthermore, you're implying (cont)
1:43 PM 9 May 12
Sandra @rhiannon1307
@femfreq that to be a 'credible feminist' a woman cannot use her feminity to her advantage and should act like a man.
1:44 PM 9 May 12
Sandra @rhiannon1307
@femfreq Which, in my book, is quite anti-feminist. But maybe you and I have a different interpretation of the term.:)
1:44 PM 9 May 12
Feminist Frequency @femfreq
@rhiannon1307 I am arguing against sexist representations of women who use their sexuality/vulnerability as a weapon.
1:49 PM 9 May 12
Sandra @rhiannon1307
@femfreq Um yes, I'm seeing that. I'm just wondering why you're doing that as it makes no sense whatso-fucking-ever. But alright ^^
1:50 PM 9 May 12
Feminist Frequency @femfreq
@rhiannon1307 I also made a video about this topic "The Evil Demon Seductress" youtube.be/_VeCjm1UO4M
Unknown 9 May 12
Sandra @rhiannon1307
@femfreq Thank you, but I really don't care.
1:50 PM 9 May 12
Mophead F@mopheadf.@femfreq @rhiannon1307 Nice vid, but now I'm seeing dehumanization on top of devaluation.